Serving employers and employees nationwide.

Get To Know Us:
Homepage
Our Services
Provider Information
Current Covered Employees
The President's Page

 


Quick Facts on Depression and Its Treatment


by Les Ruthven, Ph.D.
President & CEO of PMHM, Inc.

  1. Most persons being treated for depression receive only drugs alone from their personal physician.

  2. All types of antidepressants (Tricyclics, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, etc.) are all equally effective or ineffective in treating depression.

a. In double-blind studies using drugs alone to treat depression, an inert placebo has approximately a 32% full recovery rate versus a 50% recovery rate for the drug.

b. It is questionable whether the antidepressant is more effective against an active (as opposed to an inert) placebo, i.e., a drug that does have physiological effects but is not a drug for treating depression.

  1. Cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy by a well-trained therapist (e.g., doctoral psychologist, clinical social worker) is the most effective and cost effective treatment of depression. It has a substantially lower relapse rate than drugs alone, it is about twice as effective as drugs alone, relief typically begins after the first session, total number of sessions vary from a total of 3 to 25 sessions (depending on severity) and, even for major depression, adding drugs to psychotherapy adds little or no benefit to the benefits of psychotherapy alone.

  2. Depression is a combination of biological, personality, and environmental factors, and to call it a disease or chemical imbalance (depression does cause brain changes, and these brain changes are altered by psychotherapy) is naïve and is playing havoc with the truth. As an example of the major impact that even the cultural climate has on depression, China has by far the world's highest suicide rate among women.

  3. Giving drugs alone for depression (also giving drugs to depressed cancer patients, stroke patients, etc.) cannot be justified nor are general physicians competent to treat this complex disorder that can be life threatening.

  4. Antidepressants (except for the many patients who get better on placebo effects alone) take six to eight weeks before an antidepressant effect can begin to take place, and a person with serious depression should be referred to more immediate help, that is, referral to a specialist for diagnosis and very probable cognitive-behavioral psychotherapy.

<< Back to Top


"At PMHM our mission is to provide quality behavioral healthcare

 to our nation one employee at a time".

 

©Preferred Mental Health Management, Inc. | 401 E. Douglas, Suite 300 | Wichita, KS 67202 |

   1-800-264-7496  |  Email PMHM